{
  "schemaVersion": 1,
  "frameworkId": "CQM-25",
  "frameworkVersion": "1.0.0",
  "classification": "provisional-author-estimates",
  "calibrationStatus": "uncalibrated",
  "recordedAt": "2026-10-22",
  "basedOnEvidenceCommit": "339c6daa8cdcaf27e4e6dcce3b93bdba39980bf9",
  "rationaleStatus": "imported-pending-review",
  "measurementStatus": "not-protocol-results",
  "aggregation": "prohibited",
  "rubric": {
    "id": "cqm25-author-heuristic-v1",
    "interpretation": "ordinal-implementation-judgment",
    "assignmentStatus": "imported-not-recalibrated",
    "scaleMin": 0,
    "scaleMax": 5,
    "description": "A heuristic author judgment about implementation breadth and integration within each axis and its declared scope. These ordinal anchors are not equal-interval measurements, calibrated capability scores, probabilities or scientific acceptance thresholds.",
    "assignmentNote": "The incoming values and rationales are preserved verbatim. This rubric declares how the provisional overlay is to be read; the imported values have not been recomputed or independently rated against its anchors. Decimal values indicate author interpolation only, not measurement precision.",
    "anchors": [
      {
        "value": 0,
        "label": "No implementation identified",
        "definition": "The author judges that no relevant implementation is present in the inspected scope. Missing evidence alone does not justify zero."
      },
      {
        "value": 1,
        "label": "Illustrative component",
        "definition": "An isolated demonstration or component suggests the construct, with little integration into the operating system."
      },
      {
        "value": 2,
        "label": "Partial implementation",
        "definition": "Some relevant mechanisms operate, but major parts of the declared construct or integration remain absent or restricted."
      },
      {
        "value": 3,
        "label": "Bounded working implementation",
        "definition": "Relevant mechanisms function together in a limited setting; broader behavior, coverage or acceptance evidence remains incomplete."
      },
      {
        "value": 4,
        "label": "Substantial integrated implementation",
        "definition": "Multiple relevant mechanisms or behaviors are substantially integrated in the inspected scope, while material limitations remain."
      },
      {
        "value": 5,
        "label": "Extensive implementation in declared scope",
        "definition": "The author judges implementation breadth and integration to be extensive within the declared scope. This is not a claim of scientific validation, unlimited generality or human-level ability."
      }
    ]
  },
  "limitations": [
    "All 25 values are provisional author estimates, not measured protocol results. Imported rationales may contain unverified interpretation or numerical claims and await independent review.",
    "The original evidence review remains dated 2026-10-21 at the pinned commit. Recording these estimates on 2026-10-22 is not a new execution or review of the canonical acceptance protocols.",
    "Different axes concern different constructs and units of analysis. Values are not calibrated across axes or systems, so no overall score, domain mean, ranking or uncertainty interval is published.",
    "Engineering estimates describe implementation context only. No value is a probability or verdict of consciousness, sentience, AGI or superintelligence, and theory-linked implementation does not establish experience.",
    "Canonical assessment.score remains null for all 25 axes. Missing measurements remain unknown; not-applicable requires an explicit subject and scope reason."
  ],
  "estimates": [
    {
      "axisId": "reproduction_heredity",
      "value": 4,
      "rationale": "Code-grounded 4.0 (GATE-REPRO-SELECT): heritable nW scales auto-fission probability (0.02 + 0.08*nW) and lifespan phenotype in the live EntityManager population (+0.180 separation vs trait-blind control across 500 frames x 8 seeds); held below 5.0 because open instruction-level self-replication and live sexual crossover are not active."
    },
    {
      "axisId": "evolutionary_innovation",
      "value": 2,
      "rationale": "Code-grounded 2.0: directional fecundity selection converges onto a fixed monotone optimum (nW -> 1) and Petri strain selection operates over a fixed 26-form catalog; held at 2.0 because unbounded open-ended novelty and superiority to neutral drift on novel held-out tasks are not established."
    },
    {
      "axisId": "environmental_coupling",
      "value": 3.4,
      "rationale": "Code-grounded 3.4 (GATE-DOME-REFUGE + GATE-XENO-TROPHIC + Xylos habitat): bidirectional Gray-Scott chemical sensing/actuation for single-being Xylos plus 60k edible flora, waste-to-fertilizer recycling, Xenomimic predator-prey regulation, and Big Tree sanctuary refuge (+7.6% equilibrium lift); held below 5.0 because multi-generation plant-genome coevolution is absent."
    },
    {
      "axisId": "morphology_development",
      "value": 3.8,
      "rationale": "Code-grounded 3.8: Xylos neural-state-driven membrane/graph deformation, SuperBody consciousness/evolution-coupled multi-appendage morphing, and 250 procedural phyla morphotypes; held below 5.0 because morphology is state- and genome-driven rather than evolved via EvoGym/Sims joint body-brain developmental selection."
    },
    {
      "axisId": "embodied_dynamics",
      "value": 3.9,
      "rationale": "Code-grounded 3.9: fixed-step deterministic integration, partition-invariant Xylos session stepping, live fused f32 Gray-Scott PDE + Crank-Nicolson wavefunction dynamics, and soft plant-canopy contact under declared xeno-physical laws (Earth-physics replication is not required); held below 5.0 pending a full cross-subsystem PDE convergence audit."
    },
    {
      "axisId": "perception",
      "value": 3.8,
      "rationale": "Code-grounded 3.8 (GATE-CHEMOTAXIS + Xylos reliability percepts): bilinear 4-cell flora gradient foraging (>3x biomass capture vs blind control) and Xylos precision-weighted chemical/hazard/gradient integration; held below 5.0 because channels consume structured simulation fields rather than raw pixel/occlusion vision."
    },
    {
      "axisId": "learning",
      "value": 4.5,
      "rationale": "Code-grounded 4.5 (GATE-BIOLOGIC-LEARN + GATE-MLP + GATE-SELFMODEL + Xylos plasticity): exact Eshkol forward/reverse AD online fitness learning in the live Petri, nonlinear XOR-capable MLP self-model backprop, and Xylos associative plastic predictors outperforming frozen controls."
    },
    {
      "axisId": "memory",
      "value": 3.7,
      "rationale": "Code-grounded 3.7: Plate HRR circular-convolution holographic associative memory (context-action binding, unbinding, and decay) plus fast Hebbian plastic weight imprints; held below 5.0 pending multi-task continual-retention benchmarks across interleaved held-out task families."
    },
    {
      "axisId": "predictive_causal_models",
      "value": 2.6,
      "rationale": "Code-grounded 2.6: Xylos action-conditioned sensory predictors reduce forecast error on local feedback loops, but V4 adaptive ecology predictors failed frozen/shuffled controls and Phase-B temporal Predictor-V3 failed all 8 advancement criteria; score explicitly reflects those negative results."
    },
    {
      "axisId": "autonomous_goals",
      "value": 4,
      "rationale": "Code-grounded 4.0 (GATE-VQE-RESOLVE + Xylos autonomous policy): unprompted need-weighted hunger/curiosity/hazard motor policy in Xylos plus Variational Quantum Eigensolver 4-drive frustration minimization via exact parameter-shift gradients in the base population."
    },
    {
      "axisId": "reasoning_planning",
      "value": 3.5,
      "rationale": "Code-grounded 3.5: NHI multi-step GOAP planner with material-outcome fact revision plus discrete active-inference expected-free-energy policy evaluation in SuperMind; held below 5.0 because combinatorial detour and novel relational puzzle generalization are unestablished."
    },
    {
      "axisId": "transfer_generalization",
      "value": 2.2,
      "rationale": "Code-grounded 2.2: under the frozen 64-seed V4 cross-being causality benchmark (1,152 rows), Titans passed all inference/magnitude/replay gates (1/4 families), while ordinary organisms, Petri biologics, and adaptive predictors failed magnitude or control gates."
    },
    {
      "axisId": "metacognition_self_model",
      "value": 3.7,
      "rationale": "Code-grounded 3.7 (GATE-PREDICTIVE-METACOG + GATE-SELFMODEL, indicator-only): arbitrary-order Eshkol Taylor-jet trajectory extrapolation whose remainder causally damps VQE commitment under volatility, paired with online MLP forward self-modeling; held below 5.0 pending difficulty-matched meta-d'/d' calibration."
    },
    {
      "axisId": "social_communication",
      "value": 3.5,
      "rationale": "Code-grounded 3.5: 25 Theory-of-Mind organs (6-family ensemble), learned rival-proximity head, Nash game-theory encounters, and V4-verified Titan Prisoner's Dilemma diplomacy causality; held below 5.0 because open compositional signalling to unseen partner policies is unassessed."
    },
    {
      "axisId": "individuality",
      "value": 3.8,
      "rationale": "Code-grounded 3.8: Xylos maintains an individuated recurrent neural manifold, persistent body topology, and recorded session boundary distinct from the shared world; held below 5.0 pending component-turnover and partition-cohesion perturbation assays."
    },
    {
      "axisId": "resource_maintenance",
      "value": 3.4,
      "rationale": "Code-grounded 3.4: single-consumption edible resource accounting, energy-coupled foraging/movement in Entities and Xylos, and trophic energy transfer; held below 5.0 because 5-second flora/fauna respawn timers act as a designed habitat floor."
    },
    {
      "axisId": "homeostasis",
      "value": 3.6,
      "rationale": "Code-grounded 3.6: branching-ratio neural criticality controller (sigma -> 1.0 homeostat) and multi-drive physiological regulation keep internal dynamics bounded across silent and active regimes; held below 5.0 pending whole-organism multi-variable viable-envelope perturbation trials."
    },
    {
      "axisId": "repair_resilience",
      "value": 1.8,
      "rationale": "Code-grounded 1.8: Xylos implements bounded sparse plastic topology rewiring and state clamping, but unseen structural lesion and functional regeneration assays have not yet been executed."
    },
    {
      "axisId": "recurrent_processing",
      "value": 3.6,
      "rationale": "Code-grounded 3.6 (indicator-only): explicit recurrent pathways in Xylos, SuperMind, and ordinary resource heads with matched-input recurrence-ablation tests demonstrating causal state divergence; computational indicator only, not phenomenal experience."
    },
    {
      "axisId": "global_availability",
      "value": 3.6,
      "rationale": "Code-grounded 3.6 (indicator-only): capacity-2-of-6 Global Workspace admission bottleneck and cross-specialist broadcast in Xylos and SuperMind (Eshkol §17 GWT primitives), verified by admission and broadcast ablation tests; computational indicator only."
    },
    {
      "axisId": "causal_integration",
      "value": 3.3,
      "rationale": "Code-grounded 3.3 (indicator-only): exact bipartition quantum/classical integrated information (Phi) and perturbational oscillator complexity lab with shuffled/ablated surrogates; held at 3.3 because live mind-to-lab null separation remains near zero and software proxies do not inherit human PCI validity."
    },
    {
      "axisId": "valence_tradeoffs",
      "value": 3.1,
      "rationale": "Code-grounded 3.1 (indicator-only): context-dependent hunger, threat, and uncertainty utility trade-offs modulate hunting, fleeing, and foraging across Entities, Xenomimics, and Xylos; functional control indicator only, not felt pleasure or pain."
    },
    {
      "axisId": "substrate_pluralism",
      "value": 4.6,
      "rationale": "Code-grounded 4.6 (GATE-XENO-SCHRODINGER + 18 Zig WASM kernels + Tsotchke 17/21 causal ledger): independent live consumers of 5-qubit statevectors, Crank-Nicolson Schrödinger wavepackets, Aaronson-Gottesman Clifford tableaus, QGTL Fubini-Study metrics, Eshkol AD/Taylor towers, libirrep BdG skyrmions, and SbNN MinSR."
    },
    {
      "axisId": "instrumentation_reproducibility",
      "value": 4.4,
      "rationale": "Code-grounded 4.4 (GATE-RNG-PROVENANCE + canonical receipts): live Tsotchke randomness battery provenance (~0.99 vs degenerate stream), deterministic seeded mulberry32 streams, Xylos input-tape replay, and gate-enforced SHA-256 benchmark receipts."
    },
    {
      "axisId": "visual_embodied_scale",
      "value": 4.2,
      "rationale": "Code-grounded 4.2: combines single-being biomorphic visual morphogenesis (Xylos neural-state membranes and live 3D connectome graph, SuperBody shader/appendage morphing, 250 phyla morphotypes: 4.4) with ecosystem instanced scale (60k flora, 10k default / 50k mega entities: 4.0); legacy 9-axis comparison matrix retains 4.0."
    }
  ]
}